View source for Talk:Caligos Isle/mini games prize lists

Hey there.  I just wanted to let you know I'm going to tweak this page a little bit, but first thank you for getting it started.  Tier 1 is considered a non-prize tier, so anything like incense is actually a Tier 2 prize (basically a booby prize).  Also, there is already a heavily compiled list of Ebon Gate gems that we add to regularly.  Whatever you already have, I'm going to move to that list there and link it to this page.  Thank you. [[User:LTLPRPRINCESS|LTLPRPRINCESS]] ([[User talk:LTLPRPRINCESS|talk]]) 09:32, 7 October 2017 (CDT)

:That list of gems does not break down what is found THIS year, which is why it's in the Ebon Gate 2017 list of prizes.

::Please use 4 tildes <code><nowiki>~~~~</nowiki></code> to sign your comments.  You can use the history in the EG gems list to see what is added this year.  Gems usually carry over year to year, and there are gems found this year that were found previous years, so unless you dig back deep into history beyond what is on the Wiki, you really don't know if they're truly new. [[User:VANKRASN39|VANKRASN39]] ([[User talk:VANKRASN39|talk]]) 11:01, 7 October 2017 (CDT)

its not a list of whats new, its a list of what can be found this year. It's not reasonable to expect someone looking to find a list of gems that can be found this year to have to dig through the history of the wiki to extract that information compared to a list of gems that can be found this year being put together. [[User:JOEKUPS|JOEKUPS]] ([[User talk:JOEKUPS|talk]]) 11:11, 7 October 2017 (CDT)
:The issue is, it's not just specific to this year.  Yes, there are new gems this year.  That is certainly not up for debate.  There are new gems every year, but constant repeats of older gems as well.  This list was created to organize and maintain all the gems throughout the year in one place, as opposed to fractured and scattered throughout the various pages that creep up in the course a festival series. [[User:LTLPRPRINCESS|LTLPRPRINCESS]] ([[User talk:LTLPRPRINCESS|talk]]) 11:18, 7 October 2017 (CDT)