Talk:List of perfumes: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
(→Bottles: new section) |
(Response to PFLATS 2016 perfume bottle descriptions note. I propose new page about SCENTS in general (not only perfumes, but stationery scents, bath house oil scents, manure oil scents etc, any wearable scents). Opinions sought!) |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
I'm considering adding a second column for people to enter the description of the associated perfume bottle if they have it/know it. That way, us plebeians who don't have super rare shifting perfume bottles can find the scent. Thoughts? [[User:PFLATS|PFLATS]] ([[User talk:PFLATS|talk]]) 18:18, 17 October 2016 (CDT) |
I'm considering adding a second column for people to enter the description of the associated perfume bottle if they have it/know it. That way, us plebeians who don't have super rare shifting perfume bottles can find the scent. Thoughts? [[User:PFLATS|PFLATS]] ([[User talk:PFLATS|talk]]) 18:18, 17 October 2016 (CDT) |
||
:Good idea. But could we make a new page whose focus is "scents" in general, including: |
|||
:*bottles of perfume/cologne |
|||
:*vials of oil (manure scent etc sold at Frontier Days) |
|||
:*stationery scent bottles (also wearable like perfume) |
|||
:*bath house oils (also make you smelly) |
|||
:*any other wearable scents we can find |
|||
:I love the old page and think it should exist as-is. There seemed to be no interest in modifying it to add a bottle description column. |
|||
:Additionally, the trouble with adding bottles to that page might be, that some scents have 2 or 3 different looking bottles sold. That MIGHT muck up this current page. |
|||
:Thirdly, if a person wants to get smelly, there are so many other ways to do it than just perfumes. Why be limited to just perfume bottles? |
|||
:We could alphabetize by bottle (in the case of bath house scents, list as what they "look like" i.e. "a storm grey vanilla-scented pot"). |
|||
:PFLATS, are you still around and willing to work on this? I have a tote full of perfume bottles and a spreadsheet partly filled out which could provide a good starting point. I also have collected merchant perfume information for a few years. If my help is wanted let me know ok. Anyone have other thoughts on this? Thanks. -Soliere [[User:FIRENSIA|FIRENSIA]] ([[User talk:FIRENSIA|talk]]) 08:59, 9 February 2020 (CST) |
|||
Revision as of 08:59, 9 February 2020
I suggest reverting the alphabetization, as the order of scents is important for those who have the cycling items. Perhaps a table that would allow optional sorting? GameMaster Vanah (talk) 15:19, 21 September 2015 (CDT)
- Done. VANKRASN39 (talk) 15:37, 21 September 2015 (CDT)
Bottles
I'm considering adding a second column for people to enter the description of the associated perfume bottle if they have it/know it. That way, us plebeians who don't have super rare shifting perfume bottles can find the scent. Thoughts? PFLATS (talk) 18:18, 17 October 2016 (CDT)
- Good idea. But could we make a new page whose focus is "scents" in general, including:
- bottles of perfume/cologne
- vials of oil (manure scent etc sold at Frontier Days)
- stationery scent bottles (also wearable like perfume)
- bath house oils (also make you smelly)
- any other wearable scents we can find
- I love the old page and think it should exist as-is. There seemed to be no interest in modifying it to add a bottle description column.
- Additionally, the trouble with adding bottles to that page might be, that some scents have 2 or 3 different looking bottles sold. That MIGHT muck up this current page.
- Thirdly, if a person wants to get smelly, there are so many other ways to do it than just perfumes. Why be limited to just perfume bottles?
- We could alphabetize by bottle (in the case of bath house scents, list as what they "look like" i.e. "a storm grey vanilla-scented pot").
- PFLATS, are you still around and willing to work on this? I have a tote full of perfume bottles and a spreadsheet partly filled out which could provide a good starting point. I also have collected merchant perfume information for a few years. If my help is wanted let me know ok. Anyone have other thoughts on this? Thanks. -Soliere FIRENSIA (talk) 08:59, 9 February 2020 (CST)